For 20 years, the SSL industry made billions selling what you can get for free today. The story of how simple encryption became a gold mine, and why hosting companies still sell “premium SSL” when Let’s Encrypt works just as well.
$199 for a file.
Not a software program. Not a database. Not even a document with useful information.
A file. A few kilobytes of encrypted text that tells your browser “this website is who they say they are.”
In 2005, that’s what a VeriSign SSL certificate cost. Every single year. For every single domain. No exceptions.
Today? You can get the exact same security – identical encryption, same browser trust, same protection – for free. Takes 30 seconds to install. Renews automatically.
But here’s the kicker: hosting companies are still charging $50, $100, even $200 for “premium” SSL certificates that do nothing more than the free ones.
How is this possible? How does an industry continue to charge premium prices for something that’s been commoditized and automated?
Welcome to the story of the most profitable scam in internet history. A scam so elegant, so well-marketed, and so deeply embedded in the hosting industry that it continues printing money even after everyone knows it’s a scam.
This is how a handful of companies turned basic internet security into a billion-dollar goldmine – and why they’re still getting away with it.
In 1994, Netscape created SSL (Secure Sockets Layer) to secure online communications. The concept was simple: encrypt data between a browser and server so nobody could intercept it.
But there was a problem: how do you know the server you’re connecting to is actually who they claim to be?
The solution was digital certificates issued by trusted Certificate Authorities (CAs). These companies would verify that a website belongs to who they claim, then issue a certificate that browsers would trust.
The original plan was elegant:
What actually happened:
By 2000, companies like VeriSign, Thawte, and Comodo were printing money. They charged hundreds of dollars for what was essentially an automated process: checking that you control a domain and issuing a certificate.
The margins were insane. The actual cost of issuing a certificate? Less than $1. The selling price? $100-500 per year.
Let me break down the economics of the SSL certificate business circa 2010:
Cost to Issue One Certificate:
Selling Price:
Profit margin: 8,000% to 49,000%
Compare this to other industries:
The genius of the business model:
VeriSign was making over $200 million per year just from SSL certificates. For digital signatures that cost them pennies to generate.
By 2010, the SSL certificate industry had consolidated into what was essentially a cartel. A handful of companies controlled the entire market:
The Big Players:
These companies had browser makers add their root certificates to browsers, making them “trusted” by default. New competitors couldn’t enter the market because browsers wouldn’t trust their certificates without going through a lengthy and expensive process.
The control was absolute:
The result: SSL certificate prices stayed artificially high for over 15 years, despite the underlying technology becoming cheaper and more automated every year.
Small businesses were paying $200/year for security that cost pennies to provide. The SSL cartel was extracting billions from the global economy for what should have been a basic internet service.
In 2012, a group of technologists had enough. They founded the Internet Security Research Group (ISRG) with one goal: make SSL certificates free and automatic.
The project was called Let’s Encrypt, and it would destroy the SSL certificate industry’s business model overnight.
The Launch (December 2015):
The numbers tell the story:
2015 (Launch year):
2020:
2025:
Let’s Encrypt didn’t just compete with the SSL cartel – it made their entire business model obsolete.
After Let’s Encrypt launched, certificate authorities had a problem: how do you justify charging $200 for something available for free?
Their solution: invent artificial differences and call paid certificates “premium.”
“Better Encryption”
The claim: Paid certificates use stronger encryption algorithms.
The reality: All certificates use the same encryption standards. A free Let’s Encrypt certificate uses the same AES-256 encryption as a $500 “premium” certificate.
“Better Warranty”
The claim: Paid certificates come with $10,000-$250,000 warranties.
The reality: These warranties are marketing gimmicks with so many exclusions they’re essentially worthless. No one has ever collected on an SSL warranty.
“Better Browser Support”
The claim: Paid certificates work better in older browsers.
The reality: Let’s Encrypt certificates have 99.9% browser compatibility, identical to paid certificates.
“Better Validation”
The claim: Paid certificates provide more rigorous identity verification.
The reality: Most paid certificates use the same Domain Validation (DV) as Let’s Encrypt. Extended Validation (EV) certificates show company names in browsers, but this has proven to be ineffective against phishing.
“Better Support”
The claim: Paid certificates come with premium customer support.
The reality: SSL certificate support is rarely needed since installation is automated. When issues occur, they’re usually hosting-related, not certificate-related.
There is no technical difference between a free Let’s Encrypt certificate and a $200 “premium” certificate. They use the same cryptography, provide the same security, and work identically in browsers.
In 2017, the SSL certificate industry faced its biggest scandal ever – and most people still don’t know about it.
Google discovered that Symantec (the largest SSL certificate provider) had been mis-issuing certificates for years. The company had:
They announced that Chrome would stop trusting all Symantec certificates.
The fallout:
While this was happening, Let’s Encrypt – the “free” certificate authority – had better security practices and more transparent operations than the “premium” providers that were charging hundreds of dollars.
Higher price doesn’t mean higher security. Sometimes it just means better marketing.
Even after Let’s Encrypt proved that SSL certificates should be free, many hosting companies continue to sell paid certificates. Why?
The economics are too tempting:
Cost to provide Let’s Encrypt SSL: $0 Price charged for “premium” SSL: $50-200/year Pure profit margin: 100%
Hiding Free Options
Most hosting companies offer Let’s Encrypt SSL but bury it in confusing menus or technical documentation. The paid options are prominently displayed during checkout.
Fear-Based Marketing
“Protect your site with premium SSL!” “Don’t trust your business to free certificates!” “Get maximum security with our enterprise SSL!”
Artificial Limitations
Some hosts make free SSL harder to use by:
Confusing Terminology
The reality: Most hosting companies can enable perfect SSL security for all customers at zero additional cost. They choose not to because selling certificates is more profitable.
As basic SSL certificates became free, the certificate industry made their last stand with “Extended Validation” (EV) certificates.
The pitch: EV certificates show your company name in the browser’s address bar, providing “maximum trust” and “preventing phishing.”
The price: $150-500 per year
The reality: EV certificates have failed spectacularly at their stated purpose.
1. Users Don’t Notice Them Studies show that 99% of users don’t look at or understand EV indicators in browsers.
2. Phishing Sites Can Get EV Certificates Criminals regularly obtain legitimate business registration and get EV certificates for phishing sites.
3. Browsers Are Removing EV Indicators Chrome, Firefox, and Safari have all removed or minimized EV visual indicators because they don’t improve security.
4. Mobile Browsers Don’t Show Them Most web traffic is mobile, where EV indicators are invisible or meaningless.
2018 Study by Google:
2020 Browser Changes:
EV certificates are the SSL industry’s last attempt to justify premium pricing for something that doesn’t improve security.
Let’s do the math on what SSL certificates actually cost in 2025:
If every website used Let’s Encrypt instead of paid certificates:
Current waste:
Not only is free SSL certificate equal to paid ones – in many ways, it’s superior:
Automation
Security
Transparency
Innovation
Accessibility
The uncomfortable truth for the SSL industry: Their “premium” product is actually inferior in most practical ways to the free alternative.
The SSL certificate industry as we knew it is dying. Here’s what’s happening:
Market Consolidation
Browser Evolution
Technology Changes
Economic Reality
Prediction: By 2030, paid SSL certificates for websites will be as obsolete as paid email accounts. The few remaining use cases will be highly specialized, and basic website SSL will be universally free and automated.
Ready to stop being part of the SSL scam? Here’s how:
If You’re Choosing a Host:
If You’re Already Paying for SSL:
If You’re a Developer:
If You Run a Business:
In 2025, there is no legitimate reason for most websites to pay for SSL certificates. Anyone charging you for basic SSL is either uninformed or taking advantage of your lack of knowledge.
For nearly 20 years, the SSL certificate industry convinced the world that basic website security was a luxury service worth hundreds of dollars per year.
They created artificial scarcity around what should have been a basic internet utility. They used fear-based marketing and technical complexity to justify outrageous markups on automated digital processes.
Let’s Encrypt broke this model by proving that SSL certificates could be free, automated, and more secure than expensive alternatives.
Yet the scam continues. Hosting companies still sell “premium” SSL certificates that do nothing more than free alternatives. Businesses still pay hundreds of dollars for digital files that cost pennies to generate.
The SSL certificate scam works because:
The solution is simple:
In 2025, paying for basic SSL certificates is like paying for air – you’re being charged for something that should be a given.
The SSL certificate industry built a billion-dollar business on artificial scarcity and fear. It’s time to stop participating in the scam.
Ready for honest hosting without SSL upsells?
WebHostMost includes free SSL certificates on all plans – even the free one. No premium certificates, no hidden charges, no artificial limitations. Just secure, fast hosting with automatic SSL that works.
Start your free trial and never pay for SSL again.
And don’t forget to check our other articles!
